Cogent argument : Photo Gallery
Cogent argument : Videos
Cogent argument : Latest News, Information, Answers and Websites
R&S ATHEISTS: When is the last time any religious person made a cogent argument as to why you should abandon?
atheism and become a believing member in their religion?
Answer: i tried to understand the questions but they just did not make sense in a real world way.
so i guess never.
Category: Religion & Spirituality
cogent - Definition of cogent at YourDictionary.com
cogent definition Hear it! co·gent (kō′jənt). adjective. forceful and to the point, as a reason or argument; compelling; convincing ...
A Cogent Argument - Forbes.com
Can investors get as much of a bargain from the low-price telecom as its customers do?
Is a "cogent argument" for a Con one that inevitably leads to the conclusion Liberals are Commies!?
Through whatever nest of wacky twisted facts and innuendo?
Answer: A question like this kind of proves the opposite of your point...
Category: Politics
The Regionalization of Europe
The eurozone crisis — which is engulfing EU member states using the euro but is symbolically important for the entire European Union — is therefore a crisis of trust. Do the current political and security arrangements in Europe — the European Union and NATO — capture the right mix of nation-state interests? Do the member states of those organizations truly feel that they share the same ...
Quick, get Michael Ignatieff the smelling salts
The former Liberal chief did not go down to defeat because of his out-of-country experience
In den Medien
A Cogent Argument: Can investors get as much of a bargain from the low-price telecom as its customers do? ... Cogent Communications - Dave Schaeffer, CEO - Top 10 BSPs - FIERCE ...
Argument - New World Encyclopedia
In an argument, some statements are put forward as giving evidence for another statement. ... Instead, an inductive argument is said to be compelling or cogent. ...
Critiquing Arguments: How To Tell When Arguments Are Valid And/Or ...
Assuming that we care about those premises, then the argument is strong. Assuming that the premises are all true, then this is also a cogent argument. ...
Prosecutors, ‘Whitey’ Bulger spar over claims of judge shopping
James ‘Whitey’ Bulger’s defense lawyer has asked a judge to consolidate the two cases against his client, saying that federal prosecutors are “forum shopping” by deciding to drop an earlier, less serious case against his client. Prosecutors shot back by suggesting that Bulger was trying to do some forum shopping himself.
Now That's a Cogent Argument « Mission Mission
3 Responses to “Now That's a Cogent Argument”. mcas says: January 31, 2009 at 2:32 am. This is so retarded. T-mobile @ 17th and Valencia. Burger King @ Mission & Valencia. All the chains on Mission Street. ...
cogent: Definition, Synonyms from Answers.com
Appealing to the intellect or powers of reasoning; convincing: a cogent argument. ... Appealing to the intellect or powers of reasoning; convincing: a cogent argument. ...
True or False....An inductively cogent argument must have true premises and strong structure.?
An inductively cogent argument must have true premises and strong structure.
Answer: False.
A deductive one has those properties.
Category: Other - Society & Culture
Cogent - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Cogent can refer to: Cogency of an argument. Cogent Communications, an ... Cogent Partners, an investment banking firm focused on private equity secondary ...
If the following Argument is cogent In Philosphy 160?
The Argument is "It is unethical in America for elected officials to vote or make offical decisions on the basis of who funds their campaigns?" SO is the Argument yes or no ???????????
Answer: Agreed but it is equally unethical to allow those being supported by the government to vote for people who promise them more money from the government. It's a racket between the welfare receiver and the politician to rob the productive members of the nation via taxes.
Category: Philosophy
What is a cogent argument against global warming? - Yahoo! Answers
I would like to hear a well-formed argument that does not try to ... In spite of what the other posters have said, there is no cogent scientific ...
what is the difference between a valid and cogent argument?
i have trouble distinguishing the difference between these two. can someone help? :D
Answer: Gadfly is basically correct. Here is a good way to remember it. Validity applies only to deductive arguments and is when the truth of the premises guarantee the truth of the conclusion. Soundness is validity plus true premises.
For inductive arguments, the relevant concepts are strength and cogency. Soundness is to validity as cogency is to strength. So, cogency is strength plus true premises. But, as Gadfly mentioned, conclusions of inductive arguments cannot be certain in the way that conclusions of deductive argument can be.
Category: Philosophy
The Fallacy Files Glossary
Cogent: A cogent argument is one such that if the premisses are true, then the conclusion is more likely to be true than false. Both valid and strong ...
cogent - definition of cogent by the Free Online Dictionary ...
Translations of cogent. cogent synonyms, cogent antonyms. Information about cogent in the ... Appealing to the intellect or powers of reasoning; convincing: a cogent argument. ...
Can you please furnish me with a cogent argument?
As the senior car park attendant of a well known supermarket I object to my manager letting the security guard who is his boyfriend use the space reserved for the manager when the check out girl, disabled Doris (Not her real name) has to put her vehicle in the council car park, some one hundred metres away. The manager doesnt even own a car.
Answer: What a posh Supermarket you work for. In our local one it's a fight for survival, first come first served an' all that. Non-disabled parking in disabled spaces, young single Men parking in Mother & Baby spaces. I wish we had a Car Park Attendant, as for your Boss, well, perhaps you could announce it over the tannoy............................!
Category: People with Disabilities
The Great Misdiagnosis
Imagine a doctor who administers an elaborate treatment for a man suffering from multiple broken bones, joint arthritis, and fallen foot arches. The quack doctor orders massive amounts of liquids as though he has a horrible case of dehydration.
Additional material: chapter 3 summary (when is an argument a ...
The basic elements of a cogent argument, that is, the ARG conditions are: ... The relevance of premises is necessary for the cogency of an argument. ...
I
An argument is cogent when these two conditions apply: ... Argument D, premise 1 asserts that some percentage greater than half of a group A has ...
Beaches, Barbecues, and Tech Bubbles | Stanford Technology ...
He lays out a cogent argument for this position, including his views on current private and public tech company valuations that, in his words, “exceed any rational valuation to their current worth.” ...
Speech of Senator Juan Miguel F. Zubiri
June 24, 2011. Allow me to extend my thanks to the Konrad Adenauer Stiftung for inviting me to this conference. International gatherings like this provide instructive insights and widen opportunities for engagement toward addressing some of the most urgent issues of our time. Introduction It has been eleven...
What is a cogent argument for theism?
Category: Philosophy
Cogent Argument..........?
If a conditional argument is valid, and one of the premises is true, is the argument cogent?
Answer: No, it can't. Any good debater can argue or nit pick any point into circular reasoning based on interpretation, understanding, unknown information or the limits there of. For example can anything truly be "cogent"? To validate a condition, that condition must be proved "true", but what is definition of "true" and can actual truth be achieved? A "conditional argument" gets caught up in the many slippery slopes surrounding the conditions of the argument.
a good counter to this tactic it to be precise in your argument. Pinpoint your argument and give it know boundaries that can limit the topic. For example if your are debating the effects of inflation on the economy, then pinpoint the effects to a particular region, culture, native people, sex, education level.......ad you do this it will limit your opponents rebuttal and make your defense more sound. By taking this approach you might be able to convince listeners that your argument is "Cogent" based on your ability to pin your opponent down.
Category: Psychology
Should We Grade Filmmakers on a Curve? | Mile High Cinema
And that is totally okay, but please stop lying to yourselves and everyone else and trying to pretend you have a respectable, cogent argument by saying that we shouldn't be so hard on him for making a mediocre film ...
A Cogent Argument - Forbes.com
Jan 19, 2010 ... Can investors get as much of a bargain from the low-price telecom as its customers do?
IS THIS TRUE OR FALSE? it is reasonable to think that cogent argument with false premises has false conclusion
IS THIS TRUE OR FALSE?
1)it is reasonable to think that cogent argument with false premises has a false conclusion
2) it is reasonable to think that cogent argument with true conclusion has true premises.
3. The following is an invalid argument: If you go to Whistler, then you’ll spend a lot of money there, so, you’ll go to Whistler only if you’ll go skiing, since unless you go skiing, you won’t spend a lot of money there.
Answer: 1. Can't be determined since cogent argument only renders the truth of the conclusion if the premises are indeed true.
2. Definitely true
3.True. The conclusion of this deductive argument doesn't conform with the proposition in all facets. It is more like a fallacy of begging the question or petitio principii.
Category: Philosophy
Talk:Cogency - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
A cogent argument is one that is strong and has all true premises. ... As far as I can tell, the marble pulling example is not a cogent argument. ...
Cogency Argument True Premises Conclusion Cogent Good Strong
Cogency Argument True Premises Conclusion Cogent Good Strong Economy.
cogent - definition of cogent by the Free Online Dictionary ...
(of an argument) convincing cogent words; a cogent argument. kragtig, oortuigend مُقْنِع، قَويُّ الحُجَّه убедителен přesvědčivý tungtvejende; ...
An open invitation: Would any religionista see it fitting to write a well-reasoned and cogent argument FOR the?
existence of god WITHOUT resorting to unsubstantiated assertions? If you cant do this, then can you see why atheists DONT share your beliefs?
Answer: This is a very interesting question. To be honest I don't know that I can give you a good argument for my belief in the existence God based on any kind of fact. I don't know that anyone can really. A part of faith is believing when there is no "thing" to prove your faith. Another part of faith is the choice to believe. Choice also applies to "Not" believing. What anyone chooses is not for anyone else to judge. That is Gods job! ;)
Category: Religion & Spirituality
What is the single strongest, most cogent argument against gay marriage?
I personally support gay marriage (Im gay and married, what can I say?) I have heard many arguments against gay marriage, but they usually dont hold up very well to reasoned argument.
Im hoping someone can come up with a strong argument that actually uses reason. Quoting a passage from the Bible, and telling me that this is the way God wants it, doesnt count as an argument using reason, by the way...
Answer: I do not necessarily agree but here is the argument. The purpose of giving a married couple special rights under the law is to make it easier for them to raise children and pass their physical wealth and property on to the next generation. This is assuming that the partnership is a lifetime commitment and that children are raised (these may not be valid assumptions). A gay couple can not directly produce children. This is not to say that they do not raise any children, just that biologically they cannot produce children. The main purpose of marriage in Western culture is the production of children.
Where the gay community is falling short is in their lack of appropriately enlightening the general public about their problems having long term commitments without legal rights. No human alive is without moral sin. Some do not recognize that intolerance is a sin.
What complicates the issue in today’s American society is that there is still no scientific proof as to the reason people are gay. The general population fears that being gay is a learned response to environmental factors has little to do with genetics. Many assume that gay couples would raise gay children. This would defeat the purpose of marriage in their eyes.
Those that wish to make a moral issue out of it tend to be intolerant to others who are not part of their own subculture. Those who are misinformed tend to have no understanding about the legal issues with shared property, hospital visitation rights, insurance problems and others details of which you know but that they have never considered.
Category: Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgendered
Prosecutors, 'Whitey' Bulger spar over claims of judge shopping ...
“Rather than providing a cogent legal argument supporting his motion for consolidation, the defendant alleges that the government is 'forum shopping,'” prosecutors wrote in their filing. “In fact, the only logical explanation for the ...
Cogent | Define Cogent at Dictionary.com
Cogent definition, convincing or believable by virtue of forcible, clear, or incisive presentation; telling. See more.
couchthinking - A Cogent Argument
This is merely for personal collection - it's not often that you come across a beautifully-written piece that isn't too biased/judgmental/extremist/angsty. What's so bad about another PAP-dominated Parliament? by Donald ...
The Orchestras Decline (And Why It Wont Go Away)
"I have reached the irreversible conclusion that the symphony orchestra will always survive -- not on the weary old argument that it is somehow "good for you" to listen to "good music", nor on any cod theories that classical music breeds clever kids and better citizens, but simply because there is a cogent human need for what an orchestra adds to the relief of city life.
What is contingency? Does it have anything to do with a cogent argument?
Help, please.
Answer: I don't see any connection to creating a cogent argument.
"–adjective
1.
convincing or believable by virtue of forcible, clear, or incisive presentation; telling.
2.
to the point; relevant; pertinent."
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/cogent
This is an example of a "contingent" truth:
"Cats are mammals.
Cats are reptiles.
Cats have claws.
"The first statement is a necessary truth because denying it, as with the second statement, results in a contradiction. Cats are, by definition, mammals - so saying that they are reptiles is a contradiction. The third statement is a contingent truth because it is possible that cats could have evolved without claws."
http://atheism.about.com/library/glossar…
So "contingent" just means what ever you "wish" could be true, such as "It is possible I could have been born rich so I wouldn't have to work."
So what? How does that relevant to a cogent argument?
I agree with the assessment made by some philosophers that the the dichotomy between necessary and contingent facts is false. In this case, we cannot say "cats could have evolved without claws", because if they had done so, they would not be the animals we know as "cats" because "cats do have claws". To be cats, they could NOT have evolved without claws.
"The cognitive function of concepts was undercut by a series of grotesque devices—such, for instance, as the “analytic-synthetic” dichotomy which, by a route of tortuous circumlocutions and equivocations, leads to the dogma that a “necessarily” true proposition cannot be factual, and a factual proposition cannot be “necessarily” true.
"Only in regard to the man-made is it valid to claim: “It happens to be, but it could have been otherwise.” Even here, the term “contingent” is highly misleading. Historically, that term has been used to designate a metaphysical category of much wider scope than the realm of human action; and it has always been associated with a metaphysics which, in one form or another, denies the facts of Identity and Causality. The “necessary-contingent” terminology serves only to introduce confusion, and should be abandoned."
http://aynrandlexicon.com/lexicon/analyt…
Category: Philosophy
Ball Star | Gordon and the turnaround
Ball Stars Rustin Dodd writes that this past offseason, there were plenty of Royals fans ready to ship Alex Gordon off for the best offer. Now Gordon’s turnaround could be the Royals’ most promising storyline of the first half.
Cogency - Definition | WordIQ.com
An argument is cogent if, and only if, supposing the premises all to ... Such an argument we call cogent; cogency (that is the noun) is of central importance to ...
The Fallacy Files Glossary
A glossary defining logical terms used in the Fallacy Files. ... A cogent argument is one such that if the premisses are true, then the conclusion is more ...
Cogent Argument | Newz of Today
Cogent Argument. Harry Truman afsmeektet famous for a one-handed Economist. Why? He was sick of his economic advisers say “on the other side.” Charles Schultz expressed similar frustration here. The idea that economists ...
Intel Executive Wonders Moronically "What Intel Can Learn from Miami Heats Recent Loss" [Life Lessons]
# lifelessons Lets watch a bunch of Intel employees draw a lot of silly corporate lessons from the failure of one really good basketball team to beat another really good basketball, shall we? First, heres an executives blog post, written on the companys internal site and passed along by a tipster. Weve left off her name: More »
What is a cogent argument against global warming?
I would like to hear a well-formed argument that does not try to make its point by bashing "liberal scientists", because that is an ad hominem attack, and not a valid argument. I am happy to hear a theological argument, because I realize that in arguments between "science" and "religion", people are looking at totally different things, not just disagreeing on the same points. Be nice. Thanks.
Answer: In spite of what the other posters have said, there is no cogent scientific argument against global warming. That is why you generally see the "discussion" devolve into casting political epithets like "liberal", "socialist", "communist" and "it's a tax scam to take over the world". At this point, the only possible argument against global warming comes from the Judeo-Christian tradition of the Great Flood [the flooding of the Mediterranean basin?] and God's promise to not destroy the world again.
There is a problem with that argument, also. Look at Sodom and Gomorrah. They were destroyed, by God, after the Flood. God never promised not to destroy our civilization, only not to destroy the world. For those of you who have that religious objection, please consider the subsequent history given in the Bible. How many times were humans cast out naked into the wilderness?
Category: Global Warming
cogent - Dictionary definition and pronunciation - Yahoo! ...
Find dictionary definitions, audio pronunciations, and spellings for cogent in the free online American Heritage Dictionary on Yahoo! Education
Definition of cogent on Vocabulary.com : Vocabulary.com
When you make a cogent argument, it means your argument is clear and persuasive. In these days of 24-hour entertainment news and sound-bite sized ...
Stick to the Science
Editors note: The following is a response by climatologist Michael E. Mann to a Q&A article that appeared in the June 2011 issue of Scientific American , which became available to readers in May. Last month, Scientific American ran a disappointing interview by Michael Lemonick of controversial retired University of California, Berkeley, physics professor Richard Muller. As an undergraduate ...
cogent - Wiktionary
cogent (comparative more cogent, superlative most cogent) Reasonable and convincing; ... She presented a cogent argument, convincing her audience of the truth of her ...
Can anyone tell me a cogent argument explaining why James Madison is the most influential colonial American?
Ill be really thankful!
Answer: He's not, but if you have to answer that way bring up how he is the "Father of the Constitution". And then describe how important the Constitution is to the American political system, and how it has been the basis for all subsequent elected governments in the United States.
Category: History
sound argument = cogent argument.....?
is a sound argument the same thing as a cogent argument?
Answer: As used in logic, they are different.
A sound argument is a valid argument with all true premises.
A cogent argument is a strong argument with all true premises.
Category: Philosophy
Cogent Construction Consultants
Cogent Construction Consultants, LLC is a full service consulting company with ... Cogent Claims Preparation: If a construction problem creates an ...
Letter 2 America for July 1, 2011 - letters2america
So, considering the parties to the argument, Zakariah and Reich on one side and Loesch and the likes of Rush Limbaugh on the other, who presents the more cogent argument? Well, perhaps we should consider the sources of ...
Prosecutors, âWhiteyâ Bulger spar over claims of judge shopping
James âWhiteyâ Bulgerâs attorney has asked a judge to consolidate the two cases against his client, arguing that federal prosecutors are âforum shoppingâ as they seek to drop an earlier, less serious case against his client.
Book review: The Wizard of Lies: Bernie Madoff and the Death of Trust
Diana Henriques book is a well-researched, entertaining summary of the Madoff scandal, but it leaves some big questions unanswered. Three days. Thats how close Bernard Madoffs $65-billion Ponzi scheme came to collapsing back in November 2005.
Example of a Cogent argument?
I was wondering what kind of example could you male that would be a cogent argument with justified premises that is weak??
Answer: "Weak justifications tend to be:
Based purely on subjective opinion
Rely on an undefined ‘feeling’
Can’t be substantiated with facts or science
Are based on a cultural bias that is not universal
Are not relevant or logically linked to the facts of the case." www.nwabr.org/education/pdfs/Ethics2009/Bioethics101/4_Day_Four.doc
The strange thing is that this explanation itself is "weak" because it states that "Weak justifications tend to be:" -- not that they ARE this or that, only that they "tend" to be this or that. Very ironic, but apropos to your question.
A justification can only come when this condition is met: p is true if and only if p corresponds to a fact. This is called the 'correspondence theory', advocated (oddly) by both Plato and Aristotle, and nearly every philosopher in the west, since. It merely means that the premise "p" must correspond to some fact about some portion of reality, that portion that you are discussing in your premise. http://www.iep.utm.edu/truth/#H3
The further you get from being able to prove your premise is true, the weaker it gets. That doesn't mean it is false. But if a "defeasor" argument can easily knock down your premise, it needs more justification. It is not completely justified until no more defeasors are found to knock it down. http://www.iep.utm.edu/ep-defea/
But you must understand logic if you are going to use "deep" and complicated premises, or overcome such defeasors that are "deeper" than your premise, because the defeasor might be a fallacy that you don't see. Fallacies can always be defeated--if you see it. But fallacies are used all the time to defeat weak arguments. Fallacies are used to sell coffee and cars; they are used to sway juries; they are used to sway voters.
There are only 256 categorical syllogisms; of these, only 15 are valid. Learn those 15 and then anything you see that is outside them is invalid. You should then be able to find a way to strengthen your own argument, or produce the defeasor to someone else's premise.
Category: Philosophy
Reason and Argument
The word we use in philosophy to refer to a good argument is cogent. A cogent argument is one whose structure is such that the premises provide good reasons ...
The PJ Tatler » Geithner cites the 14th amendment to justify ...
I have yet to see a cogent argument suggesting even a remote Constitutional issue. June 30, 2011 - 6:00 pm Link to this Comment | Reply. 4. Gbm. Do not forget about Section 5 of the 14 Amendment. Section 5. ...
The divided states of Europe
Europe continues to be engulfed by economic crisis. The global focus returns to Athens on June 28 as Greek parliamentarians debate austerity measures imposed on them by eurozone partners.